ResellerRatings
Store Ratings Best/Worst Stores Stores by Category Top reviewers FAQs
For Companies

Full Rating Profile + -

Product & services pricing
5.00/5
Chance of future purchase:
5.00/5
Shipping & packaging:
4.07/5
Customer service:
3.75/5
Return/Replacement policy:
0.00/5

Verified
5/5

2018-05-11

"Amazon pay is great "


Verified
5/5

2018-05-09

"Was fast quick easy to use and link up through Amazon account"


Verified
1/5

2018-05-06

Poor sleeve suggestion in spreadsheet

"The spreadsheet on the site recommends "Magnum Gold" for DragonMaster. Upon opening the package and seeing the size I was convinced you shipped the wrong item. After reviewing the order and your site I found it's your spreadsheet at fault here. I'd prefer you didn't make a recommendation for sleeve on this game at all. There is just too big of a difference in size between the card and sleeve to make them usable. ~$6 down and the hunt for sleeves continues."

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges

Verified
5/5

2018-05-05

"Finding the right card sleeves was quick and easy."


Verified
5/5

2018-05-05

"bought my scythe sleeves here, really enjoyed it"


Verified
3/5

2018-05-01

Better price than FLGS, but I shopped outside the sale and now I regret missing it by 2 days. Wait for the sale, don't shop till then.

"I regret my decision to purchase. 2 days later, a major sale went on that could have saved me about $17 in card sleeves (about 25%-30% of my order). Part of me wants to return them and then repurchase, but lesson learned. I won't ever buy card sleeves in bulk again until there is a sale. Unfortunately, I bought enough to sleeve all my games, so I guess it doesn't make a difference now. Lastly, the Standard Card Sleeves are pretty poor quality, guess I didn't understand how flimsy they were. I would recommend going with a different brand for a similar price."

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process

Verified
4/5

2018-05-01

Good deals on sales but website is awkward to navigate

"Overall, everything was fine, I hope. I will wait to see if I get the right cards. The problem was that when going to a particular size of sleeve, it shows several options. The site doesn't let me select among the options. I'm just hoping that I got the sleeves that I ordered."


Verified
5/5

2018-05-01

Great Service

"They keep up with you and send you updates"


Verified
5/5

2018-05-01

Awesome company

"They seem to care about their customers, and they offer great products. "


Verified
5/5

2018-05-01

Stupid review

"Quick. Except this feedback part that is really annoying."


Verified
5/5

2018-05-01

Excellent sleeves

"Always able to find sleeves to fit all our games and they have held up well through multiple playthroughs"


Verified
4/5

2018-04-30

Smooth order, expensive shipping

"As the catchy title says. Smooth to order, a bit expensive on the shipping but I can't find the French Tarot anywhere else... :)"


Verified
5/5

2018-04-28

Keep comming back

"As my boardgame collection expands, mayday has been there to keep it protected. "


Verified
5/5

2018-04-25

Love the Quick Checkout!

"I love that I can go right to my cart, click the PayPal icon, and all shopping is complete. Hard to find anything that efficient anywhere else."


Verified
5/5

2018-04-25

Good Product. Good Prices.

"I like what you make. I wish it was a little easier to search sleeve sizes and navigate the website. I couldn't find what I wanted just by typing in 80 x 80 into the seach box. I had to manually expand the info from the names of the card sleeves in the menu. Maybe list the card sleeves by name and by size so I don't need to expand all just to find the right size? Also having to expand the "more" option to find more sleeves seems like an extra step. Just show them all."