ResellerRatings
Store Ratings Best/Worst Stores Stores by Category Top reviewers FAQs
For Companies

Full Rating Profile + -

Product & services pricing
5.00/5
Chance of future purchase:
5.00/5
Shipping & packaging:
4.07/5
Customer service:
3.75/5
Return/Replacement policy:
0.00/5

5/5

2020-07-03

Trickerion “All-In” Sleeves

"Quality product, timely shipping! I love that I can shop by game and that I don’t have to worry about measurements.

Fellow Trickerion Shoppers: I got mixed up and realized when the sleeves arrived that this sleeve pack is for (I think) the *original* All-In Kickstarter from the game’s initial launch. I have the Collector’s edition, so I ended up 100 45mm x 68mm sleeves shy. So if you have the Collector’s Ed, be sure to tack on extra tiny sleeves to your order!

Also! I learned that since the premium sleeves are thicker, it becomes more of a game to smush cards down and slap the storage lids on quickly. So you may want to go standard for this version of the game. Everything still fits, though, so no stress if you want the extra protection!
"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process

2/5

2019-01-11

Penny sleeves

"Would never have ordered such flimsy sleeves."


5/5

2019-01-11

Excellent service , great communication and cooperation. Fast processing.

"Excellent service , great communication and cooperation. Fast processing. Really professional work.Highly recommended."

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service

5/5

2019-01-05

Card sleeves kickstarter

"Excellent service. Many thanks"


1/5

2018-12-21

Took 2 months to ship something I was told would ship in 1 month

"Ordered some card sleeves on September 29th, they shipped 2 days later, and I received them about a week and a half later. Ordered card sleeves November 12th, was told by the giant banner that nothing will ship until November 26th (would have ordered sooner, but because of the confusing wording, I thought they were out of stock and I couldn't order), my order apparently didn't make the cut for their "Black Friday early shipping" they emailed me about for November 23rd (thanks for the useless email), then I was emailed December 17th that my sleeves finally shipped, and I received them the 20th.

No explanation was ever given why the exact same sleeves I ordered in September that were apparently still in stock would suddenly take until late November to ship, no explanation, apology, or anything given for shipping an order out almost literally one month later than they said they would ship it.

I was going to buy a set of about 2000-3000 premium sleeves for my now complete Sentinels of the Multiverse collection, but considering they dropped that item for no apparent reason and that they haven't said a word about what in the world caused a one month shipping delay off an already 2 week shipping delay, I doubt I'll continue ordering from Mayday ever again.
"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process

1/5

2018-12-19

Ordered on Black Friday.. it still has not even shipped.

"This is insane. How can a retailer either not be prepared to have product shipped for Christmas, or be properly stocked to account for expected sales? It's not like they shouldn't be aware it's the biggest retail holiday in the US. They were prompt to reply but the fact that I haven't even had this order ship yet is absurd. I am probably going to cancel it because I don't need a million excuses why. There's other providers to use, and this will certainly be the last time I order anything with them."

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process

1/5

2018-12-19

3 weeks processing?!

"It took 3 weeks for them to ship my order. I heard that their restock was caught up in customs, but that is just hearsay. I don't know what the real reason is, because I received ZERO communication from Mayday! I placed my order on 11/26/18, and received tracking on 12/18/18. Terrible customer care."

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process

1/5

2018-12-17

NOT a smooth transition

"Poor communication. Super slow order processing and shipping, even when I had to pay for Priority shipping. I had to sent couple emails asking for order status because the seller never provided updates.
Order was placed on Nov 24, 2018 and today Dec 17, 2018 (after sending and email inquiring Mayday for order status), the order status appears as "Shipped". Hope it arrives before Christmas...

This is the second time I order from Mayday games and in both times I have had similar experience/issues.
"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process

1/5

2018-01-01

Horrible Customer Service

"I placed an order on 11/15. When I placed the order, it did not say no inventory or low inventory. If I had known you did not have the sleeves I needed in stock, I would not of ordered thru you and ordered elsewhere. I received an email 4 days after I placed the order, that did not specify what was being shipped and what was on back order. And to make matters worse, I had to contact them to find out the status of my remaining order. I received the other part of my order today, 2 WEEKS AFTER MY INITIAL ORDER.

I WILL NEVER ORDER FROM MAYDAY GAMES AGAIN
"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Overall customer service
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges

5/5

2018-11-20

Amazing

"Cheap, fast and the excellent quality of mayday!!"


3/5

2018-11-20

No package tracking

"Tracking link gives a 404 error "

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process

5/5

2018-11-08

Pretty cool service

"Its a pretty cool service, never thought I might actually need card sleeves but after numerous and long gaming sessions it becomes obvious that they are a necessity."


3/5

2018-11-06

Order cancelation

"Hello. After placing my order I noticed it was incomplete and sent you a message to cancel it so I can reorder again. Please check the situation and provide me feedback."

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process

5/5

2018-09-18

Great Service, Re-seller of Sleeves

"I find their service just perfect. with their new website its so much easier to navigate through the website. Deliveries have always been on time in perfect condition. Only problem with their Re- seller site is that there is a major stock issue so i rarely end up buying sleeves in bulk only due to stock issues. Their pricing is awesome from a re seller perspective. "

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges

5/5

2018-08-20

fast shipping, quality product

"easy to find product, easy to buy through PayPal, fast shipping, good product"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall product shipping and delivery process