"I ordered a Magic the Gathering Commander deck. The card was charged, but the product never arrived. Repeated attempts to contact the company were unanswered. I cannot recommend this merchant."

"I sold on TCGplayer for years and would have kept doing so if they never instituted their Direct system. As far as I can see, the TCGDirect system is designed to give TCG more money on the backs of the smaller sellers. Since this system was instituted my sales haven't just plummeted, they have flatlined. I haven't sold 1 card since, even though I have an inventory of over 1 thousand cards listed. If you not the cheapest or in their system, your cards will NOT sell.

As a buyer, I think the conditions I get and service from sellers is great. I avoid at all costs the Direct system to help the smaller guys out."

"Ridiculously high fees and Draconian policies make being a profitable seller here almost IMPOSSIBLE. As a buyer it's easy to scam a seller and get free cards, 99% of the time, as there is no seller protection.

If you're a scam artist or want to make no money after paying fees, TCGPlayer is for you!

Customer Service is all email based, you will never talk to a real person, EVER."