ResellerRatings
Store Ratings Best/Worst Stores Stores by Category Top reviewers FAQs
For Companies

Full Rating Profile + -

Product & services pricing
5.00/5
Chance of future purchase:
3.75/5
Shipping & packaging:
5.00/5
Customer service:
3.75/5
Return/Replacement policy:
3.34/5

5/5

2022-03-05

Great Customer Service

"Madison Seating was quick to respond and resolve the situation when my order arrived damaged."


5/5

2022-02-26

Five Star Customer Service

"The team at Madison Seating was so helpful in replacing my office chair. FedEx lost the package and Madison Seating helped me find the package and ensured it was delivered. Unfortunately, the package was damaged by FedEx but Madison Seating was quick to respond and super helpful in replacing the product. I would recommend ordering from Madison Seating. "

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges

5/5

2022-02-25

Good Customer Service

"Customer service was great in responding into any inquiries I had about my office chair that I ordered. "


5/5

2022-02-24

Faster than expected delivery and prompt customer service

"I ordered a HumanScale Liberty Task Chair from Madison Seating. The chair arrived ahead of schedule. When the chair arrived I unpacked the chair and found the seat shell was damaged. Annie from customer service was super nice and told me that I did not have to send the broken chair back and they offered to replace the chair with no additional charges. Very satisfied with customer service and I am looking forward to my new chair. "

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Overall customer service
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges

1/5

2022-02-14

Don't expect to ever receive your purchase.

"I bought a chair that was listed as in stock at the beginning of January. Their website and receipt email said that products will be shipped in 10-14 business days. When I heard nothing in that time frame, I contacted the company. THEY WILL NOT TAKE ANY CALLS ABOUT SHIPMENT, only calls for new orders. If they already have your money, you are told that you must contact them through email only. I sent and eventually got an email back, saying, so sorry, with COVID their shipping will take much longer and my chair would be shipped in early to mid February. They have since tried to cover their butts on various sites by saying they have told people that it would take longer. However, at the time I bought the chair both the website and the receipt email very clearly said 10-14 days for in-stock items.

It's mid-February, and it's the same song and dance routine. I emailed and I called the company, despite their autoattendant saying that existing order issues will only be handled through email. I got someone right away, so... so much for not having people available to handle issues. Of course, I got the same garbage, saying that they can not provide any shipping information or a refund by phone, only via email. I noted that the people handling emails have telephones too, so please connect me to the person(s) who is handling emails. Of course, it was the same thing repeated over and over... can't give information about shipping, can't cancel and refund a purchase that hasn't been shipped over a month after the initial promise, can't connect a person to anyone who can discuss it...

DO NOT BUY FROM MADISON SEATING.
"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process

4/5

2022-02-06

Aeron chair half the price of a new one, set your expectations accordingly.

"The good:
- The chair looks new...I actually expected more wear/blemishes for a refurbished chair. I've sat in Aeron chairs for the entirety of my professional career, and I wanted one for my home office. I know where they tend to wear (base, where the back hits the desk) and saw not signs of wear in these locations.
- When I emailed Madison regarding expected date of delivery, they responded to my email very quickly, even on a Sunday.

The bad:
- I ordered mid December and received my chair early February. I can expect some of the delay due to Covid, but 45 days for the most common Aeron chair in existence is a stretch. Madison's website notes 15 business days.
- The base was touched up with a paint that is off-gassing. It is gradually diminishing, but I would recommend leaving the chair in a well ventilated room for a few days before putting it into a confined space.

So do I think I got a reasonable deal? Yes. Would I recommend you order from Madison? Only if you know what you are getting into, and I wouldn't recommend ordering anything other than a very common office chair with standard features.
"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process

1/5

2022-01-25

Utter garbage

"Bought a chair from Madison seating. Without reading their reviews first (WHOOPS)

The chair never comes.

We get a refund from Amazon. (Thanks, a-z team.)

The chair finally shows up 10 days outside the delivery window. Box is trashed.

Madison sends 3 emails before 1pm the next day demanding we ship the item back or face prosecution (lol), NY Small claims (LOL LOL!)

Give me a break, chair sellers. I don't work for you. Even the call center at amazon.com knew you should have corrected the ship to address when you knew the refund had been issued.

How do you guys even turn a profit?

We contact amazon 15x pleading that Madison send a box. C'mon. I got nothing to lose. Just send a stupid box for your counterfeit chair and get it the hell off my porch 55 days after I ordered it.

Nice folks at Amazon tell them NUMEROUS TIMES to send a box or forget it. Amazon tells me not to contact them. Ok, not a problem here.

Finally... They send a smaller box with what??!!? A NEW SPARE CHAIR BACK inside - Yep. A brand new Herman Miller chair back. Wow. Will wonders never cease.

We talk to the Fed Ex guy who stops by every day to drop off stuff. FedEx refuses to pick it up without a box and proper packaging materials- and sorry, I'm not spending a dime for you Madison Seating team. Fed ex comes and goes and the parts just sit on the porch in the rain and the snow. Pretty sad chair out there in the cold.

When they finally call and I pick up the phone to speak to the "customer service" rep and ask why they haven't sent a box, she asks who my wife is and "WHATS THE NAME OF YOUR FARM?? ARE YOU A FARM?"

I tell her that none of that is any of her business.... and she tells me that I will "be getting a call from the Boss tomorrow!" and I let her know to tell him to save the dime and send a BOX!

I let her know that she was an idiot, to which she responded that I was actually the idiot.


"Yep, an idiot with a free chair. Bye!"

Then, Madison stalks my family and I and calls incessantly from a caller ID blocked number --- (Thanks for the subpoena help, T-mo! ) - and as soon as they call again, the Call Trap app will track the number and number of calls :)

ATTN: Madison seating: How much time have you wasted out of your life? Shouldn't you have just sent a box? You've obviously spent more than the value of an old used chair (AND SPARE PARTS LOL) and should have just swallowed your pride and sent the box. Good heavens. Look at all your real reviews, and the ones you can't flag.

Send a box. You need a life and should sell better chairs. People might actually like you.
"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges

1/5

2022-01-18

Dishonest seller

"Deceitful seller!
Listed as ‘open box’ An item in excellent new condition with no wear.
I received a ‘used chair’. It smelled like an old home. The arms were scratched up, had a lot of damage, was painted over. The upholstery had stains and wrinkling on the top and bottom.
Also the base was silver in the pic and I received a black base.
Upon contacting the seller they tried to justify that it is a good price and said it’s a $1200 chair. That is bs! On the Design Within Reach website, $1100 is for a brand new chair with upgraded material. This actual chair brand new goes for $595. The chair they sent is only worth $100 at the most!
Another shady thing about them is they switched this ‘Setu’ chair i purchased and changed the photo on the listing an ‘Aeron chair’. Once I left them negative feedback, they were able to remove my feedback and the picture changed back to the ‘Setu chair’ they sent me in a misrepresented and horrible condition. On top of it all, they raised the price i bought it at ($299) to $349.
I hope want this to stop their lies and inconveniencing the buyers.

This was their response:

New message from: madisonseating (5,906Green Star)
Dear Customer,

This was a close out item that was discounted from $1100 to the sale price of $300 you received. Minor cosmetic wear was to be expected.

Please dis-assemble the chair and place it back in the original box.

Print the attached, pre-paid FedEx return label: 775694810217 and affix over original shipping information.

PLEASE WRITE ON THE BOX BOLDLY #535646

The item must be received back in our facility within 30 days in the original box and packaging material.

Best regards,

Returns
Madisonseating
"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges

5/5

2022-01-12

Exceptional customer service and great experience!

"Recently purchased an office chair and was very pleased with the quality of the chair. Besides the chair quality, the customer service was exceptional. They were extremely helpful and answered questions about chair in general. Overall, it was a phenomenal experience and will definitely use them in the future!"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges

5/5

2021-12-28

Great Customer Service

"I ordered a chair on their website. The chair arrived faster than expected. When the chair arrived the box was damaged and upon trying to assemble the chair I realized the chair was also badly damaged. They were great I did not have to send the broken chair back. I just took photos of the damage and emailed it to them. They offered to replace the chair with no additional charges. Highly recommend this company."

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges

5/5

2021-12-06

Customer Service Responsive and Attentive

"We ordered several chairs which one of the chairs had an issue. They were very quick to respond and seek to resolve the issue for me. The team is very happy with the chairs. I would recommend buying from them. "

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges

1/5

2021-11-29

Zero Stars SCAM

"If I could give this company zero stars I would. Do not buy from this company. It is a scam at best. It clearly states on their website that they will not charge your card until they provide you with shipping information. I ordered a chair 10/29/21 and my card was charged on 11/2/21 and I was not provided with any shipping information. I contacted the company via email and had a back and forth conversation with Sana and the answer to when I would receive shipping information was changed twice in this conversation. So I decided to do the smart thing and cancelled my order. My boyfriend also cancelled his order at the same time on 11/11/21 and he received a refund notification whereas I did not. I called my credit card company and let them know what was going on and my credit card company suggested I do a charge back. TWO WEEKS LATER I receive an email (on Thanksgiving no less) with a quite threatening email demanding I return the money that was refunded to me and that I had now received two refunds. My bank account did not reflect this until TWO DAYS LATER, so, since I used to download credit card reports and call credit card companies when people used to try and scam my company out of services, I suggested that Maddison Seating contact my credit card company, as I know company to company they can resolve this. I received an email reply back threatening me with legal action if I did not call my credit card company myself. Now this sh*tstain of a company can have a grand ole time waiting their up to 30 days for their return all because their “billing” or “chargeback department” didn’t check their credit card reports before issuing me a refund. This was not my fault, or my credit card companies fault. Maddison Seating has a poor reputation and that reputation has proven itself with this interaction. I will be contacting the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, the Federal Trade Commission, and the New York State Attorney General about their scammy business practices. Do not buy from this company. "

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges

1/5

2021-11-23

awful

"Terrible company to work with. I ordered a remanufactured Leap chair and with all the hidden charges I might has bought a new one. 2 months after I received it the cylinder would randomnly trigger. I thought it might have a whole in it but as I found out later it can also be because if the cylinder was installed improperly you can accidentally trigger it. I have ordered leap chairs before direct from steelcase. They usually comes 100% assembled. Madison sends them to you in three parts. The base + cylinder + seat. I may have installed it wrong causing the above problem. Madison had me send the chair back to them. I asked for a suggestion on how to send a bulky item like that thinking it was going to be expensive. I did not get much of answer. So I go to UPS. Was charged $280. Didn't like that but I got the chair so I'm kind of stuck. Madison also charged me for the return trip $75. That really **** me off because they could have told me they would be charging me for a return trip and they could have helped me make that more affordable but did not. Steelcase's policy on this is Steelcase pays for all shipping for up to 12 years. So I paid $400 for the chair + $280 to send in for repair and $75 to get it back from repair. "

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges

5/5

2021-11-09

Good Customer Service

"Madsion Seating makes customer service a priority. I ordered a chair which had an issue and they quick to resolve that for me. I recommend buying from here"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges

5/5

2021-11-04

Responsive Customer Service

"I purchased an ergonomic office chair from Madison Seating because my significant other bought on last year from the same seller and absolutely loves it. The turn around time from purchasing and receiving my order was exactly two days - which was significantly earlier than I was expecting which was super cool! Once the chair arrived, I found that the leveler to adjust the height didn't work so I reached out to customer service and received a reply the same day. They asked that I send a video depicting the problem and upon analyzing the issue, they offered to send me a brand new chair - I was super impressed by their quick service and appreciate their willingness to listen to their customers needs!
"

Detailed Review Benchmark + -
Pricing of products and services
Likelihood of customers making future purchases
Overall customer service
Overall product shipping and delivery process
Product Returns/Refunds/Exchanges