"I was a seller on Atomic Avenue for 13 years. I recently left the platform on 20.11.23 and had orders to the total of $634.50 for which they never paid me for. As far as I am concerned they are a bunch of crooks. I will be taking the matter further and taking legal action against this company and its owners Pete Bickford and Carolyn Bickford."
"The unique aspect of Atomic Avenue is this is a "sellers" platform. ComicBase or anyone else connected to the site receives no funds from the sale of a comic, magazine or book. If you have a bad experience, announce to the entire platform who this seller is. I've been a retailer since I opened my store in 1993, my Facebook page can be found -- at https://www.facebook.com/HawgHeadComics -- and I've been a retailer at TCGplayer since May 2020. I work hard to maintain my rating. If a seller doesn't make a "bad situation" better, then let us know. Don't group all of us in the same box."
"I "stumbled" upon this site a few months ago. I have had nothing but great experiences. Accurately graded books and at worst you pay a reasonable price if not a great bargain. I highly recommend."
"I love Atomic Avenue. I have ordered hundreds of comics from about 15 different sellers and only had one disappointing experience. There is a large selection at good prices from many sellers. Some are professional sellers some are just people selling parts or all of their collection. It's also a great site to go on just to see all the titles and covers a comic company as put out thru the years. They show them even if they don't have any for sale."
"Received quickly, packaged well."
"I ordered a comic and the buyer cancelled my comic. Unlisted it and refused to have it shipped because of his mistake."
"Very neat comics site with an awesome number of cool and oddball comics for sale.
Found a great deal on a mini-series I've been trying to complete forever and got my comics in three days flat! Everything was in the condition promised and the packaging was good.
This seems like one of the best kept secrets for comic lovers on the interwebs. Will definitely shop here again!"
"Probably my favorite way to buy comics on the internet. Incredible number of comics, and I've scored some amazing deals. I agree with the person who said it's smart to check your seller's ratings (good advice for any system). I've personally never had a problem with shipping, and the sellers there seem to go the extra mile."
"I've had some very good experiences with buying on Atomic Avenue. Every site has a few bad sellers (ebay and Comic Collector included) but I've found some really good deals and honest merchants through Atomic Avenue and the others. Be careful and read the individual reviews/feedback."
"Atomic Avenue has been a horrible experience! One of my comic orders didn't even show up. Another order was canceled due to the person had the wrong comic. People, buy your comics somewhere else!"
"AtomicAvenue.com is a total rip off. Buyers Beware! If you are lucky enough to even receive the comics you bought, 90%+ of the time, they are in terrible, not as described condition. Look around online and read the reviews about this website before joining. I have yet to see a good review for this website and have experienced nightmares in trying to purchase from their website."