2/5

posted Jun-15-2011
This issue was resolved amicably with the merchant, although I did have to pay a 10% restocking fee and pay for return shipping, I will get a refund for a good portion of what I paid for the mirror. Thanks for working with me!!!
Like the buyer several reviews down (toilet seat), I purchased a copper mirror for our new basement bathroom on 5/29/11. Received packaged very well (inside 2 boxes). Clearly no damage in shipping. We did not open it immediately, but when we did, we noticed a slight "flaw" on the upper arch of the mirror. I waited about a week, and called Signature Hardware (my Order # was SHW505409). Talked with a Customer Service Rep. She sent me an e-mail that I could use to send them pictures of the mirror, which I sent that Monday. The same day or next (not sure), she responded that she talked with her manager, and they would take mirror back less $50 to cover shipping. I got a quick quote from my work's UPS ground shipping and found it would probably only cost me $20 to ship myself. I offered to do this and meanwhile found out they told me I could NOT return the mirror because I had 5 days to report any DAMAGE (I never knew about this policy), and clearly the mirror was not technically damaged, there is a flaw in the workmanship/craftsmanship of the piece (and the way it was created). They reiterated that there was nothing they could do, and then today I find out that they told me I MISUNDERSTOOD and that I would have to PAY them an additional $50 for a new mirror and I'd have to keep the mirror that I have (meaning NO refund of any sort, and I'd have to pay an additional $50). I told them I'd just go to the Better Business Bureau to try to work this out. Meanwhile I filled out their on-line survey that I found in my e-mails from a week ago, so at least I hope someone higher up in the company finds out about this. An hour or so ago, I get another e-mail from their CS Mgr. stating that they would send me a new mirror (she is now "authorized" to do so) if I would pay to ship the old one back. How am I to know if the new mirror is going to be any different than the old one? And quite frankly, after the 5-6 e-mails and phone calls and pictures taken, etc., I am BEYOND aggravated with this company. They're trying to hide behind their fine print on their website, which clearly states you have 30 days to return any item, less a restocking fee of 10%. I was perfectly willing to do this. But as soon as I said the word "dent," they told me it was damaged, and I could not return it (for a refund). Well who is supposed to stand behind this--they should, they are the seller. If that means collecting from their manufacturer, I have to believe that's the cost of doing business. And they kept trying to blaim it on the shipping (so that they could then file a claim with UPS/Fed Ex or whomever shipped it). I just cannot, in good conscience, say it was damaged in shipping, because it wasn't. So bottom line, BEWARE, because now I'm stuck with a mirror I cannot use until I get to the bottom of getting a refund (and I will). I AM going to contact the Better Business Bureau. I spend thousands on-line each year with various on-line sellers and quite frankly have never come across anything like this. And it's not as if I'm being unreasonable ... I agreed to pay for the return shipping and even a restocking fee ... even though the mirror came to us with this flaw. Had I "lied," and never told them of the flaw, I could have returned the mirror within their 30 day return period (which isn't up until 6/29), and nobody would have been the wiser. I guess that's what you get for being honest and trying to work things out!!!

This review was modified by
Swoosh60 on June 16 2011 07:12:14 AM
“Hello Swoosh60,
I'm sorry it took so long to get your order. I'm glad everything did work out for you, however! You will be happy to know that our warehouse updates have been completed and all of our orders are shipping out normally. Yay! :]
Best wishes,
Corina C.
6pm.com”