5/5

posted Oct-24-2004
I've had my Puget system for only 10 days, so can only address the buying experience, my impressions of the system, and of the quality of the tech support based on the (very) few problems I've had.
Buying experience: Best/most personal I've ever had. Unlike storefronts or the "biggie" Web sites (Dell, HP, etc.), the people who review the configuration you've chosen know computers first hand. They even tell you that you don't need something and can save money by eliminating it! They responded rapidly (usually same or next day) to questions I asked before and during the build. System was ordered on 9/28/04 and shipped 10/6/04 by the cheapest method (5-business-day ground). I got it 10/13.
What did I get: Asus P4P800SE mobo with Intel P4 3.0GHz (Prescott); mobo includes onboard sound, network controller, and supports RAID; 512MB PC3200 DDR RAM; Western Digital 80GB drive; MSI GeForce MX 440 64MB 8x AGP video card; Lite-On 8x DVD±RW/CDRW combo drive; Creative Labs fax modem; Enermax 350W "Whisper" power supply; Vantec CPU cooling fan; Nero Express 6; and Windows XP Home, all housed in a Lian Li mid-tower.
Impressions of the system: It's unlike anything you can get from the "biggies". I had stipulated a quiet system, so the component of most interest was the Lian Li case. All aluminum with three fans. Sound insulation on side panels, and a front cover with rubber seals, all designed to dissipate heat rapidly and quietly. The case added a lot of $ to the cost. Is a special case like this worth it? Depends on your needs. As you see from the configuration, my needs are minimal; this is not a gaming computer, and I don't need 12 drives (which is the capacity of the case). Because of it's potential for holding far more devices than I'll ever need, the system has a total of 6 fans: the 3 that come in the case, the Vantec over the CPU, and two in the power supply. The Vantec is noisy and vibrates slightly. The system IS quieter than the one it replaced, which had a total of 3 fans, but not as quiet as the Dell 4600 that I had for 48 hours before sending it back (a long story for which there's no room here)! The point is that unless you're extremely knowledgeable about computer hardware, you can spend extra $ on things that wind up meeting your needs no better than something less costly. I.e., I could have gotten a smaller case with fewer fans and no sound insulation that would probably have been as quiet as this one. The case does a good job of quieting the 6-fan racket inside… but IMO, this modest system doesn't need that much ventilation, although since heat is the #1 enemy of solid-state devices, it will probably prolong the system's life.
Layout inside: Beautiful. Instead of the wire gaggle you get with mass-marketed systems, this one is laid out almost like a schematic; all wiring neatly bundled and out of the way, everything easily accessible.
Software: Best approach to loading software that I've ever seen. First, you get NOTHING you didn't ask for. No "try AOL", AOL messenger, Dell Jukebox, and on and on. It came loaded with only Win XP, Nero Express, and the drivers required for the devices. Second, all drivers and software are the latest version. WinXP, for example, came with SP2 already installed. And the disks you get with it are not proprietary (like Dell's Windows or ResourcesCD). You get a REAL Microsoft-produced Windows XP-SP2 disk! The entire system is tested for 24 hours to make sure everything works.
Tech support: Fabulous. E-mails are answered same or next day. The owner, Jon Bach, even e-mailed me the solution to a minor BIOS problem. It is a completely different experience than I've had with biggie tech support where the reps have a thick accent, are talking to you over scratchy lines, have no in-depth knowledge of hardware or software, and read the answer to your question from a database of "boilerplate solutions".
Price: It's unlikely you can get a Puget system with the same hardware for the price of a mass-produced biggie computer. Mine cost almost 50% more (delivered) than a Dell with the same devices. However, does that make the Puget system "more expensive"? That question is difficult to answer. IMO, judging whether or not something is "expensive" depends on what you get for what you pay. For example, while a Dell has a mobo, is it an Asus? Does it support RAID should you ever want to do that? It has a DVD±RW/CDRW drive, but who made it? Is it a Lite-On, which has a solid reputation? Is the case metal or plastic? Is it sound insulated? Are the fans ball bearing (the ones in the Lian Li case are)? Can you even get such a case from a biggie? Does it contain proprietary parts that bar you from using industry-standard hardware? Is the tech support worth a tinker's damn?
Would I buy from them again: You bet! Based on the experiences I've had thusfar, all of my next computers will come from Puget Systems.

This review was modified by
Rover on October 24 2004 09:19:22 AM
“We are so sorry for the trouble you have had getting in touch with us! I handle a good portion of our email correspondence, and I was not able to locate a message previously sent from your email address - it is possible it might not have gotten through our spam filters like it should have. This is something we will certainly look into! We do our best to respond to customers as quickly as we can online, but sometimes it is much quicker to contact us by phone. Our customer support team can be reached at 888-321-2552 (weekdays 6am-6pm PST or weekends 7am-4pm PST); our hold-time is never long and we are always happy to help with any issue.
In regard to the expiration dates of the cartridges you received - the expiration dates printed on individual cartridges will often be much sooner than the expected shelf-life of the item itself. Generally, though, we do not recommend purchasing a larger inventory than that which would be used within 1 year. The reason for this being simply that our warranty is 1 year long - we want to be able to help you should you encounter any trouble. If you are unsatisfied in any way, we do offer a 1-year 100% satisfaction guarantee on all of our products and are happy to set up a return/refund for any unsatisfactory items. Just give us a call at 888-321-2552 and we can set this up for you. I hope this helps!
-Alex P.”