59,985 stores
1,896,562 reviews
Over 250,000 shoppers online now
Our WeeElite Program recognizes excellence in customer satisfaction. To display the ResellerRatings Elite badge, companies must meet stringent ratings standards, and they must subscribe to the ResellerRatings Merchant Member program to actively participate in resolving customer issues at ResellerRatings.
Minimum 8.00 lifetime rating, 50 minimum lifetime customer reviews or Minimum 8.00 six month rating, 25 minimum customer reviews in past six months.
* Any rating below 8.00 disqualifies a merchant for Elite.
ResellerRatings Elite is not a guarantee or a warranty that you will receive excellent service, but companies that qualify for ResellerRatings Elite have the highest customer satisfaction ratings of any companies listed on our site.
If you see the ResellerRatings Elite badge on a website that does not appear to qualify, please let us know.
41 reviews ![Facebook share](javascript:share_rating({"link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/McGivern_Diamonds","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/McGivern_Diamonds.jpg","store_name":"McGivern Diamonds","store_rating":"10.00","total_reviews":"41"}, "store");)
Share your shopping experience and interact with
1,986 participating stores,
write a review!
Follow us & win cool gear: 
Rating
Store Info
Full Rating Profile
Visa / Mastercard
American Express
Discover
Priority Next Day
International
Online Ordering
This review was modified by 
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"Fantastic experience all around. Mike was extremely knowledgeable, easy to work with and very accommodating of my needs. The ring couldn\u0027t have been more \u0022perfect\u0022 (according to my fianc\u00e9). Highly recommended!","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/McGivern_Diamonds\/review\/1538624#comment1538624","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/McGivern_Diamonds.jpg","store_name":"McGivern Diamonds","username":"Bohemeths","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"McGivern Diamonds was a great experience. Dealt with the owner Mike direct. Very helpful with everything from picking out the right center stone and type of ring. I will definitely be purchasing any type of jewelry through them.","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/McGivern_Diamonds\/review\/1527844#comment1527844","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/McGivern_Diamonds.jpg","store_name":"McGivern Diamonds","username":"THicks","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"I was very skeptical about ordering an engagement ring online. Mike McGivern worked with me via email to put my mind at ease about making a purchase of this size online and sight unseen. Their prices were significantly better than any of my local stores. When the ring arrived it was exactly what I had pictured and my fianc\u00e9e loved it. I will continue to use McGivern Diamonds for future jewelry purchases and recommend them to my friends.","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/McGivern_Diamonds\/review\/1523938#comment1523938","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/McGivern_Diamonds.jpg","store_name":"McGivern Diamonds","username":"Ryan13","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"Mike gives excellent personal service. He is there to educate and made sure I was happy with what I received. I asked to make a switch in my order after the return policy had expired, and Mike didn\u0027t question it. He wanted me to be happy with my diamond. Even offered to let me ship under his insurance. Thank you, the diamond is beautiful! -Malin","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/McGivern_Diamonds\/review\/1511573#comment1511573","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/McGivern_Diamonds.jpg","store_name":"McGivern Diamonds","username":"Malin","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"I found McGivern Diamonds while googling for wholesale prices. There are so many choices on the web site and even more in the catalogs at the store in Perrysburg, OH. It was an hour drive, but well worth it because we found Mike to be so comfortable, sincere, and helpful with our choices and provided full service to view the stone, size the ring and ship fedex to our home. We were so pleased that we have made a second order through Mike via e-mail. Very easy, fast, and reliable with high quality gorgeous products.","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/McGivern_Diamonds\/review\/1510337#comment1510337","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/McGivern_Diamonds.jpg","store_name":"McGivern Diamonds","username":"chrisscollard","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"I am very pleased with my transaction with McGivern Diamonds. The website is fantastic. Mike is very personable and professional and informative. He responded to questions promptly and updated me on my order status the whole step of the way. I would recommend McGivern Diamonds and look forward to doing business with Mike and McGivern Diamonds again. Great prices, great quality, great service. I love the diamonds I purchased from them. They are exquisite. ","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/McGivern_Diamonds\/review\/1468107#comment1468107","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/McGivern_Diamonds.jpg","store_name":"McGivern Diamonds","username":"give2012","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"I would like to say , it was a pleasure dealing with McGivern Diamonds. The service, communication and of course the diamond ring where all five star. This was not a simple transction and all went as promised with only a minor glitch in communication on the shipping, with no harm or risk associated. I\u0027m a return customer and would certainly recommend there sevice to others. ","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/McGivern_Diamonds\/review\/1457465#comment1457465","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/McGivern_Diamonds.jpg","store_name":"McGivern Diamonds","username":"plynne","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"Michael worked with me to select a gorgeous diamond. I only had two weeks to get the ring before going on vacation and he had it ready and to my door almost a week early. Very easy to deal with and a great ring at a great price.","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/McGivern_Diamonds\/review\/1448819#comment1448819","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/McGivern_Diamonds.jpg","store_name":"McGivern Diamonds","username":"Excited","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"We are extremely satisfied with our purchase and experience from McGivern Diamonds. The price was more than fair and the customer service was exceptional. We ended up doing an exchange, as the first diamond we purchased wasn\u0027t what we were looking for, and the process was seamless. I would highly recommend McGivern\u2019s Diamonds, and we will definitely use them again in the future. Thank you for everything Mike! ","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/McGivern_Diamonds\/review\/1446655#comment1446655","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/McGivern_Diamonds.jpg","store_name":"McGivern Diamonds","username":"scottmac711","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"Awesome experience. Spoke directly with Mike a couple times, he was very helpful. When I wasn\u0027t happy with the first diamond (which was my fault for not reading about EGL vs. GIA) Mike was more than happy to exchange it. He helped me pick out a diamond that was perfect and I had the new ring back in 3 days! I definetly recommend McGivern diamonds!!!","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/McGivern_Diamonds\/review\/1444399#comment1444399","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/McGivern_Diamonds.jpg","store_name":"McGivern Diamonds","username":"Nikkimillward","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
"Great Customer Service. Like any other procrastinating man, I ordered a Mother’s Day present for my wife a little too late. I later received an e-mail letting me know that it wouldn't arrive prior to Mother's Day and they had asked if that was perhaps what the purchase was for. When I mentioned it was, they went out of their way to rush it so it arrived just in time."