60,022 stores
1,906,578 reviews
Over 250,000 shoppers online now
132 reviews ![Facebook share](javascript:share_rating({"link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","store_rating":"9.50","total_reviews":"132"}, "store");)
Share your shopping experience and interact with
1,986 participating stores,
write a review!
Follow us & win cool gear: 
Rating
Full Rating Profile
Visa / Mastercard
American Express
Discover
Money Order
COD
Check
2-3 Day Delivery
International Order
posted Jan-15-2013 
posted Nov-14-2012 
This review was modified by 
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"I was a first time customer and I will be a repeat customer! They have great customer service, have great prices, and are a company of their word.","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc\/review\/2284667#comment2284667","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","username":"MageE68","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"CoolStuffInc has a great selection and an awesome rewards program. The shipping rates are reasonable. However, what sets CoolStuffInc apart is the fantastic customer service. I made a mistake on one of my orders with the shipping info and thanks to their help it was sorted out almost immediately.","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc\/review\/2064051#comment2064051","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","username":"JohnA1990","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"A very good buying experience! Pre ordered the newest Magic The Gathering cards and it shipped on release day and was delivered without problems. Will order many more time from them!","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc\/review\/1955031#comment1955031","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","username":"Epsilon69","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"CoolStuffInc does a great job! They have good prices, a nice rewards program, and great customer service. I\u0027ll definitely be shopping there again.","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc\/review\/1274981#comment1274981","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","username":"Tarn","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"I wish I could \u0022pick a star\u0022 higher than very satisfied; this is my 14th transaction with CSI - 10th this year, and I can\u0027t sing their praises loud enough. You might find a couple of dollars difference on a few things if you shop around, but once you combine their customer rewards program with their free shipping for orders greater than $100, how can you beat that? So, Cory and the rest, thanks again!","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc\/review\/1074433#comment1074433","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","username":"david_g_walls","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"Great! No problems! Will buy from them again!","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc\/review\/1009185#comment1009185","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","username":"louis-662","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"CoolStuff Inc. delivered what was ordered in a timely fashion and did not gouge on shipping\/handling charges to Alaska. Would definitely order from them again!","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc\/review\/992407#comment992407","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","username":"jrobbins-643","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"great place to buy games and they have great prices and offer customer rewards.","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc\/review\/985265#comment985265","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","username":"javajoe96","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"Great, prices were awesome and shipping was fast.","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc\/review\/982941#comment982941","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","username":"aarondm4","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"Very good job. I got the products I wanted in good condition, delivered extremely quickly.<br>","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc\/review\/977691#comment977691","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","username":"junker359","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"15 orders from me so far!","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc\/review\/944543#comment944543","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","username":"curtca","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"I ORDERED 90$ WORTH OF MAGIC CARDS,ARRIVED IN 10 DAYS TO GREECE,VERY PLEASED.THEY HAD THE BEST PRICE ON NET FOR EUROPEAN BUYERS,LOW SHIPPING TOO.THANK YOU!","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc\/review\/935856#comment935856","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","username":"airborne.gr","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"Needed to buy some cards to participate in a tournament my friends were running, and didn\u0027t want to pay extra mark-up for cards at the local store. So, I came here to buy them. I used the $0.99 shipping to buy some Innistrad packs, and ordered on a Thursday. They shipped on Friday morning, and arrived on Tuesday, plenty ahead of time, packed in a small box. All packs accounted for. Snagged an Olivia Voldaren! I\u0027ve bought packs from the twice before, also no complaint. ","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc\/review\/915499#comment915499","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","username":"gfunk49","rating":"5"}, "single");){kind=link}
![Share](javascript:share_rating({"review_body":"I\u0027ve placed four orders at Coolstuffinc, all for MTG singles. The first one(around $100) arrived in perfect condition after 8 days (to europe). The second (about $150) never arrived, i contacted CSI after 30 days -they just replied with the tracking number (which had no trackings in europe). Paypal returned me the money. Third order ($140) arrived after 9 days. Fourth order ($260) was \u0027hold for review\u0027 because it was for above $150 and my paypal account was not verified. I phoned them and tried to understand why it suddenly needed to be verified. I suggested that I could pay with VISA directly on their webpage instead to bypass this sudden need to \u0027verify\u0027, and they said that it would work. So I did, and then all of a sudden they needed me to verify my credit card information and give them bank information. I did so immidiatly. It\u0027s now been three days and my order is still being \u0027held for review\u0027. The amount has been pulled from my card...<br><br>Im not going to order from them again, and suggest you consider other alternatives if you live outside of the US.","link":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/CoolStuffInc\/review\/876071#comment876071","store_thumb":"http:\/\/www.resellerratings.com\/store\/thumbnail\/CoolStuffInc.jpg","store_name":"CoolStuffInc","username":"khenso","rating":"2"}, "single");){kind=link}
"Great, reputable online store for board/card games."