First, I will not make any assumptions about the status of this company. Just the abbreviated facts regarding my situation with them:
I have purchased parts and assemblies from Monarch for years. This represents many thousands of dollars worth of gear. We had been reasonable toward each other about any issues (large and small), and as a long-experienced system builder, I enjoyed the competency I saw from them in the past so much as to commend and recommend them (particularly for parts and customer service).
After placing an order through Monarch’s system configuration / compatibility menus back in October 2005, I found out after some testing that the motherboard did not cleanly support the entire 4 GB of RAM I had ordered with the system. So, I contacted them about the problem.
---
Monarch’s response (10/13/2005)…
"The combo has already been assembled and shipped. The Asus premium motherboard does have problems with certain types of ram at 4GB. If you have any problems with the combo or would like to return the board for the other, let me know.
Thanks,
Kevin / Monarch Support Team"
My response (10/17/2005)…
"Hello Kevin,
Thank you for your quick reply, and WOW!... *extremely* fast service.
After upgrading my content creation workstation with the new guts and doing much testing, I've come to the conclusion that the well-featured and beautifully built mainboard should stay. It has many good I/O options and cooling features that I need, built in.
Had hoped to get 4GB in the box performing reasonably to make ready for heavy 64-bit apps when they come down the pike. Looks like that won't happen just yet. Not with this particular processor, anyway.
The memory is already fairly high latency at spec timings, and the mainboard will only run the 4 double-sided modules with further-reduced speed, and even then, perhaps not reliably. System cannot be made to run AT ALL with all 4 at their spec clock, so I did not bother to deepen testing with all 4 banks loaded. Not worth the trouble.
Just one pair still requires 2T command rate to post. System tests out 100% clean in memtest86+ after many passes at stock timings and the 2T command rate though, so... good enough for now.
Can I get an RMA number for one of the memory kits?:
Memory: 140346 - DDR (400) 3200 - 2 GB (2 pcs 1GB) OCZ
I will go ahead and keep the one set running and purchase a more compatible / high performance matched set of 4GB for this system if/when that is made available with real certainty.
Thanks again,
<me>"
Monarch’s reply (10/28/2005)…
"This is to advise you that we have entered your store credit in the amount of $205.00
When you place a new order, on the bottom of the screen is a PO field. Enter the RMA number in this field (EX. "RMA 25669 "). Once you receive the confirmation for the order, immediately reply that you would like to use the store credit for this order. Please keep in mind that store credits are only valid for up to one year of the credit memo date.
Please let me know if you need any additional information.
Also, please keep in mind that orders processed on the website will be completely billed to your credit card or pay pal account, and in turn, the store credit will be refunded back to your account once the order had been processed.
If you have used your store credit, please disregard this e-mail.
Thank you and have a nice day,
Melissa L.
Monarch Computer Systems
Return Department"
---
Recap; I was issued an RMA and "store credit" for the return of 2 of the 4 matched memory modules back in October 2005.
RMA #: 0025669
RMA Date: 10/21/2005
On a subsequent purchase (dated 9/9/2006) I applied the store credit precisely as described by Melissa L. at Monarch Computer. This was within the 1 year window to use the credit. The recent purchase (a Raptor HD) was paid in full by me and delivered by Monarch in good working condition and in reasonable time. As usual, they billed the full amount almost immediately after my online order was placed.
Monarch’s acknowledgement to apply the promised store credit (email date: 9/11/2006)…
"Your RMA credit is currently being applied to your order. Any credit available to you will be refunded back to you."
Note; this was *not* signed by any Monarch CSR.
It is now 12/4/2006 (almost 3 months later) and there has been no application of that promised $205 credit to either the purchase or my account.
All further inquiries regarding the matter have gone unanswered.
Wishful thinking, perhaps, but I’d like to see them make good on our arrangements.
This review was modified by its author, GetImpact, on
12/4/06 2:36 PM.