Looking at 2 video capture cards, any help please

[big_blue_ram]

Hi all,

first time poster

looking at two video capture cards

Gigabyte GV R92128VH - Graphics card - RADEON 9200 - AGP 8x - 128 MB DDR SDRAM - video capture adapt

or

Asustek ASUS V 9520 Video Suite - Graphics card - GF FX 5200 - AGP 8x - 128 MB - video capture adapt


I want to transfer all my old football video's onto DVD.

what do you think is the best option, thanks All

Dez

[muno]

Uh, between those two, I'd go with the radeon.
Looking at the options, you don't seem to be a hardcore games, so even better might be some older model of all-in-wonder radeon which also has a tvtuner
-M

[big_blue_ram]

Well I have a NVIDIA GeForce4 Ti 4200 with AGP8X just now but true, I dont have many games on my machine, just GTA Vice City (hooked on that) And Madden 2003

I only mentioned both of the above as they were the ones I found, so if anyone has some suggestions, I would be very happy to listen.

I just want to be able to make all my videos into DVD's

thanks for replying

[slinky]

between those two, the 5200 would have better performance in games.

the 9200 might have a little better of image quality though.

checkout the TV LEADTEK WINFAST "DELUXE" TV2000XP TV/FM MULTIMEDIA CARD. you can get this cheap @ newegg for a low $50.

edit: the 9200 would have the same image quality as the 5200 since it simply does not have the power to run high AA/AF.

[Kruzin]

Get a real capture card, not some all-in-blunder garbage.
With a real capture card, you can keep your existing video card, and upgrade that when you want, while keeping the separate capture card.
Matrox RTx10 or RTx100 are the way to go for Real Time video capture/editing.

http://shopmatrox.com/usa/products/c...ID=69&Column=2

[muno]

The guy's looking to transfer his football videos, not making T4.
(I wouldn't pay min $600 for that...)

Basically any card that's vivo (video in/video out) will do for you.
-M

[Darthgary]

Originally posted by slinky
between those two, the 5200 would have better performance in games.

the 9200 might have a little better of image quality though.

checkout the TV LEADTEK WINFAST "DELUXE" TV2000XP TV/FM MULTIMEDIA CARD. you can get this cheap @ newegg for a low $50.

edit: the 9200 would have the same image quality as the 5200 since it simply does not have the power to run high AA/AF.

Ther FX 5200 has nothing on the Radeon 9200 but DX9 woopty doodaa.


Any way maybe go with a ATI TV Wonder VE, I have one and it works great, got mine for $50 at best buy.

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applicati...&Sku=A177-2122

[Prexaspes]

http://www.newegg.com/app/manufactor...alog=47&DEPA=1

No point in buying another video card. Just get a video capture card.

[Darthgary]

Unless you want a better video card also!

[squads]

his ti4200 is a better vid card then either of the all in one cards anyway