Welcome to TechIMO
Hmm sorry not familiar with HP's ... but what size power supply is the old one? Or did you upgrade that as well? (edit: sorry just noticed the wattage of the PSU

)
I had a similar problem once, turned out the motherboard was grounded out by an anchor that shouldnt' of been there
May want to try taking the mobo out of the case and trying to power it on there...
Make sure you put the mobo on something NON conductive