Found out what the problem was...don't know why this didn't occur to me in the first place.
These plans are on normal 8x11 paper...not blueprints. Someone reduced the plans in order to make them fit on the paper and that totally screwed up the scale. lol.
Granted that still doesn't really help me with the measurements that I need...but at least now I know
WHY the measurements didn't come out even though they used the same scale.
Uggghhh. Is it Friday yet? lol.