Remove the heatsink, clean off all thermal paste as good as you can, (removing the CPU will probably be necessary under good light). Look very closely at the core of the CPU...some call it the die. This is the heart of the processor, and it is jammed full of transistors. The "plastic" covering that you see, is very thin..and brittle as glass. Installing or removing a heatsink improperly will damage the core edges/corners...this instantly kills the CPU...sorry.
Check out the following page. It is of a dead Duron CPU...and was damaged by attempting to install a water block..same as installing a heatsink....wrong.
http://www.bunkermentality.net/protection.html
Right after the "A" type CPU came out...the successor to the K6-2 series with the metal cap protecting the core, I read where as many as 1 in 8 home builders were killing their CPU's by incorrectly installing (or removing) heatsinks.
Someone then invented a shim..to assist with heatsink install or removal without damaging the CPU..these were made from copper, and many people thought it was for heat transfer , but it was not.
I still use a shim..but today, you can get non conductive shims that take the load off of the core edges/corners while installing the heatsink.