From what I read of it, it definetely is something that the courts would have to decide, because what I read sways me both ways on the subject
He got the name for free, and Network Solutions got nothing in return for the registration. However, in all the other legal mumbo jumbo, it seems that there is indeed a claim.
Yikes! This is unfortunately why we have to have laywers, and not just for court, but to avoid going to court....jeesh.