As you found them on Craigslist, are they local to you? If so, definitely take a trip to the physical store to look or purchase directly from the brick and mortar store.
Here's the address/phone numbers from their website:
Closeout Bargains
Phone number (845) 610-3550
Fax number (845) 610-3549
Chester Mall Plaza
78 Brookside Ave.
Chester, NY 10918
At this time there have been no reviews submitted on Closeout Bargains / furniturevariety.com. Nothing negative seems to be popping up on them via
Google.
A 30% restocking fee is high. Also, what about shipping fees? Many times reduced profits from drastic markdowns are recovered from exorbitant shipping and handling fees. As you would be purchasing heavy, bulky furniture, it would be wise to carefully consider these costs - and your costs for return shipping PLUS the 30% if you get defective items, or need to return for whatever reason, etc.
If nothing else, pay with a credit card only - never pay cash/western union/wire transfer/bank transfer/egold, etc., and do not shop at a store that will not take your credit card.
When you are anxious to get settled into your new life and being tempted to impulse buy is the exact time to slow down, take a deep breath and tread carefully. There are many furniture stores out there so you have a lot of options. You will not regret having patience and doing thorough research when it comes to these major purchases. I know this from experience, having been down that road
Btw, welcome to ResellerRatings.com and congratulations on your upcoming marriage.